I always hear some politicians say they favor a “two state solution” to the Israel/Palesitne conflict.
The problem is (A), like it (or believe it) or not, there are already more than two states. In fact, there are four: Jordan has been a Palestinian state since 1946. Israel departed from Gaza in 2005, making it a second Palestinian state. In Samaria / Judea (AKA, “the west bank”) there is Area A and Area B. So in effect there are actually four separate Palestinian states. But this will not satisfy. They won’t be satisfied until Palestine occupies everything “from the river to the sea.”
There is actually another, more pertinent, problem (B): The “Palestinians” don’t actually want a state of their own. They have been offered such a state numerous times, beginning in 1937 (1) (the Peel Commission); then in 1947, (2) UN Partition Resolution 181, (which Arabs answered by starting a war); then in 1967 (3) another offer was made (In July 1968, the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) hijacked an El Al airliner, marking the start of international airplane hijackings and hostage-taking operations designed to force the Palestinian issue onto the global agenda. Meanwhile Arab leaders elsewhere issued the Khartoum Resolution: “No peace, no recognition, no negotiations”); then in 1978-79 (4), they were offered self-governance in Samaria/ Judea and Gaza, (Arabs responded with militants hijacking a bus near Tel Aviv, killing 38 Israeli civilians, including 13 children. Militants operating out of southern Lebanon continued launching Katyusha rockets and cross-border infiltrations into northern Israel, including the April 1979 Nahariya attack by the Palestine Liberation Front (PLF) that killed four Israelis.); another offer in 1993-95 (5), (resulting in Hamas launching a campaign of suicide bombings inside Israel ); then in 2000-01 (6), Bill Clinton proposed a state in Gaza plus 91% of Samaria /Judea (Yasser Arafat rejected it, and the Second Intifada occurred ); then in 2008 (7) Israeli PM Ehud Ohmert offered 94% of Samaria /Judea and all of Gaza; (Arab militants militants in Gaza responded by continuing to fire Qassam rockets and mortars into southern Israel); in 2005 (8) Israel unilaterally withdrew from Gaza, basically forcing them to accept a state of their own; (this resulted in the election of Hamas to govern Gaza, and ultimately to the events of October 7th 2023).
October 7th 2023 was “the straw that broke the camels back.” On October 7, 2023 the the militia of the government of Gaza (aka, Hamas) launched a large-scale surprise attack from the Gaza Strip into southern Israel. The assault killed nearly 1,200 people and resulted in the abduction of 251 hostages, making it the deadliest day in Israel’s history and sparking the subsequent Gaza war. Here are some details:
- Beginning around 6:30 a.m. on the Jewish holiday of Simchat Torah, militants fired over 4,300 rockets into southern and central Israel as cover for a ground invasion. Thousands of armed fighters breached the Gaza–Israel security barrier at dozens of points using explosives, bulldozers, motorized paragliders, and boats.
- Militants overran Israeli military installations and infiltrated more than 20 civilian communities, including kibbutzim such as Be’eri, Kfar Aza, and Nir Oz, as well as the city of Sderot.
- Gunmen attacked the Nova Music Festival, an outdoor trance music festival near Kibbutz Re’im, killing 378 attendees and taking dozens of others captive.
- Approximately 1,195 to 1,200 people were killed, the vast majority of them civilians, alongside roughly 367 Israeli security personnel. Victims included Israeli citizens as well as dozens of foreign nationals, including 46 Americans.
- Militants took 251 living and deceased captives—including infants, elderly civilians, soldiers, and foreign workers—back into the Gaza Strip.Subsequent United Nations and independent investigations documented widespread massacres, torture, mutilation, and sexual violence committed by militants during the assault.
The terrorists were very proud of their accomplishments and recorded their assaults using body cameras. Camera footage shows children being mutilated (alive) in front of their parents, and parents mutilated in front of their children. Infants were shoved into microwave ovens; children were beheaded along with their parents. Women and girls (some as young as five, and as old as 90) were gang raped repeatedly, until their pelvises were broken and bloodied. The militants took special care to make their sexual assaults as brutal and painful as possible. In many cases victims were burned alive.
The most heinous thing, I believe, is the attitude that some Progressives have taken in justifying the actions of Hamas. Certain U.S. university professors and anti-Israel activists view Israelis as foreign settler-colonizers comparable to 19th-century European colonists. Through this ideological lens, proponents argue that all Israelis are complicit in colonization and lack a right to safety or security. The U.S. Party for Socialism and Liberation stated immediately after the attack that the actions of the resistance were a morally and legally legitimate response to occupation. notes that Some academics and activists praised the attack as a strategic “achievement” that disrupted the Middle East status quo and brought Palestinians closer to ending Israel’s existence.
It’s ok for Palestinians to rape, murder, pillage and plunder the elderly, infants and children but for Israel to retaliate with conventional military tactics aimed at rooting out the perpetrators is genocide.
At this point I am at a loss for words. Before now I could never believe that Americans of any stripe could justify the acts of barbarism inflicted upon a peaceful population who want nothing more than to live their lives.
