A question about the Gaza “Genocide”

If it’s really a genocide why are there any Palestinians still alive?

*It’s been 3 years, 1 month and 9 days since Israel began it’s retaliation for the Hamas attack of 10/7/2023.

The IDF is one of the most powerful, technologically advanced, and well trained militaries on Earth. If Israel’s intent was genocide surely it should be over by now. In fact there shouldn’t have been a single Palestinian alive by 11/7/2023 (One month since Hamas’ invasion). It probably wouldn’t have even taken that long.

Only an absolute FOOL would believe Israel’s armed forces are this inept. Did you not know that Israel has low-level-radiation tactical nukes? They could have wiped Gaza off the face of the map within 24 hours of 10/7//2023, IF genocide was their intent, and by now they would have rebuilt the place into a luxury seaside resort.

There are a lot of lies repeated concerning Israel, but this genocide lie is by far the stupidest, most transparent lie of them all.

Want to talk about a real genocide?

On October 7, 2023 the the militia of the government of Gaza (aka, Hamas) launched a large-scale surprise attack from the Gaza Strip into southern Israel. The assault killed nearly 1,200 people and resulted in the abduction of 251 hostages, making it the deadliest day in Israel’s history and sparking the subsequent Gaza war. Here are some details:

  1. Beginning around 6:30 a.m. on the Jewish holiday of Simchat Torah, militants fired over 4,300 rockets into southern and central Israel as cover for a ground invasion. Thousands of armed fighters breached the Gaza–Israel security barrier at dozens of points using explosives, bulldozers, motorized paragliders, and boats.
  2. Militants overran Israeli military installations and infiltrated more than 20 civilian communities, including kibbutzim such as Be’eri, Kfar Aza, and Nir Oz, as well as the city of Sderot.
  3. Gunmen attacked the Nova Music Festival, an outdoor trance music festival near Kibbutz Re’im, killing 378 attendees and taking dozens of others captive.
  4. Approximately 1,195 to 1,200 people were killed, the vast majority of them civilians, alongside roughly 367 Israeli security personnel. Victims included Israeli citizens as well as dozens of foreign nationals, including 46 Americans.
  5. Militants took 251 living and deceased captives—including infants, elderly civilians, soldiers, and foreign workers—back into the Gaza Strip.Subsequent United Nations and independent investigations documented widespread massacres, torture, mutilation, and sexual violence committed by militants during the assault.

The terrorists were very proud of their accomplishments and recorded their assaults using body cameras.  Camera footage shows children being mutilated (alive) in front of their parents, and parents mutilated in front of their children.  Infants were shoved into microwave ovens; children were beheaded along with their parents. Women and girls (some as young as five, and as old as 90) were gang raped repeatedly, until their pelvises were broken and bloodied. The militants took special care to make their sexual assaults as brutal and painful as possible. In many cases victims were burned alive.

Genocide is defined under international law as specific acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group.  It is limited strictly to national, ethnic, racial, or religious groups, omitting political groups.
It requires distinct intent to annihilate the group, separating it from general war crimes or crimes against humanity.

The key here is “distinct intent.”  In it’s attack on October 7th, 2023, Hamas clearly demonstrated it’s intent to kill as many Jews as they could lay their hands on (and they recorded it with body cameras). The taking of hostages was merely an attempt to create a bargaining chip for later use.

Neither the state of Israel not any of it’s leaders have ever been recorded as stating they wished to annihilate the entire Arab population of Gaza, or of Areas A and B of Samaria / Judea (aka: “the West Bank”).  In addition the IDF has bent over backwards to warn civilians of upcoming operations, telling them via phone calls, dropped leaflets, radio, television and internet broadcasts to relocate to safe zones. They also facilitated the delivery of over 603,000 polio vaccinations to Gazan children under the age of 10. If genocide was the IDF’s goal, wouldn’t be more efficient to just let the children die?

*(This writing was posted on 11/7/2026)

 

Author: El

Progressive Zionist, Father of three sons, Grandfather of four boys, four girls, and Great grandfather for one great granddaughter. Jewish, Druid, Pagan, Hin-Jew, Hin-Dru, Bu-Jew, Bu-Dru, Non-Dualist, Spinozian Pantheist, Life Long Democrat, Writer, Purveyor of unconventional wisdom.